Is the withholding tax on interest applicable to non-resident beneficiaries of a trust?
04 February 2015
Posted by: Author: SAIT Technical
Author: SAIT Technical
Would non-resident beneficiaries of a trust be subject to new withholding tax
(WHT) on interest? Where a SA trust pays interest income to a discretionary
non-resident beneficiary would such interest fall within the ambit of the WHT
exemptions in terms of section 50D(3) of the Income Tax Act are not applicable
as these non-resident beneficiaries are not physically present in SA for more
than 183 days nor is the debt effectively connected to a permanent business
establishment of that non-resident which is registered for tax.
therefore of the view that such interest would become subject to this
withholding tax as the wording of section 50C is very broad and would cover
this scenario. However, others are of the following view: A
"distribution" from a trust would not be regarded as a
"payment" of interest from resident to a non-resident as the
beneficial owner of that interest is the trust until such time as the trustees
exercise their discretion to distribute (i.e. not the same as pay) that
interest to the non-resident beneficiary. Therefore such distributions should
not fall within the ambit of the WHT on interest provision.
This is a complex part of tax law and may require an expert opinion. For
purposes of our guidance we assumed that the non-resident beneficiary doesn’t
have a vested right to the interest – in other words, it is a discretionary
right. It was also accepted that the interest is not payable in respect
of a loan from the non-resident. We accept your view that none of the
exemptions (section 50D) apply and also assume that the relevant treaty, if
any, doesn’t provide otherwise. In essence therefore, the interest accrued to
the trust from a source in the RSA and will be paid out to a foreign person
(the beneficiary) in consequence of a decision by the trustees. Section 25B(2)
will apply to this. The effect of section 25B(2) is that, for tax purposes, the
interest so vested in the year of accrual is deemed to not have been received
by the trust, but by the beneficiary.
is our view the payment by the trust to the beneficiary is merely a form
of distribution (i.e. distribution is a collective term to transfer value from
the trust) by a trust and therefore the two concepts are not necessarily
mutually exclusive. Where an amount of interest is distributed by way of
approved payment and such amount constitutes interest accrued to the
beneficiary (i.e. section 25B ITA) then we agree that it would be subject to
withholding in terms of section 50B ITA if the beneficiary is a non-resident.
In our view this would be intended, otherwise the whole regime can be
circumvented by just inserting a SA Trust between the SA payor and non-resident
recipient which would not be intended from a tax policy perspective.
may want to obtain the view of a tax specialist or a ruling from SARS in this
Disclaimer: Nothing in this query and answer should be construed as
constituting tax advice or a tax opinion. An expert should be consulted for
advice based on the facts and circumstances of each transaction/case. Even
though great care has been taken to ensure the accuracy of the answer, SAIT do
not accept any responsibility for consequences of decisions taken based on this
query and answer. It remains your own responsibility to consult the relevant
primary resources when taking a decision.